November 18: When to believe the words over the actions.

November 18, 2026•3 min read
Custom HTML/CSS/JavaScript

A woman in one of my Facebook groups posted a question that echoed many conversations I’ve had over the years with friends and with clients.

She’s been in a situationship for two years with a man she’s known for twenty.

He pursued her.

He also told her, clearly, that he doesn’t want a relationship, just something casual.

And yet.

Good morning texts.

Good night texts.

Constant contact all day long.

He tells her she’s a good woman.

That she’s amazing.

That left her asking the question that’s breaking her heart:

“If I’m all those things, why am I not being chosen?”

She finally told him exactly how she felt.

He’s been silent for three days.

She asked for advice, and she asked for gentle.

So here’s (gently) what I told her.

I’ve seen this over and over, and it almost always comes down to mismatched behaviors and mismatched interpretations.

We all carry a mental list of couple-coded behaviors.

The good morning text.

The “you’re amazing.”

The all-day check-ins.

To her, those are relationship switches.

Flip enough of them and the lights come on.

To him?

He’s just being himself.

And therein lies the problem.

He’s been open and honest about what he wants, but his actions keep flipping switches in her brain that his words never agreed to.

No one’s fault.

Her brain simply can’t read his behaviors any other way.

I have a word for this in my dictionary:

Wishtening.

/ˈwis(h)t-ə-niNG/

verb, wishten

The highly developed talent for hearing only the emotional subtext one wants to hear, effectively muting any inconvenient truths or dissenting opinions.

It affects roughly 98% of humans in relationships at some point.

(Yes, probably you. Definitely me.)

And the low dating bar makes it far worse.

So many people we date barely meet the minimum standard for kindness that when someone is genuinely warm, even casually, it feels like they’re performing relationshipping.

So she has two choices:

  1. End the casual connection to protect herself.

  2. Rework her interpretations and enjoy what she has, without looking for more from him.

Both are valid.

Both will be painful.

Now the flip side, for anyone who’s ever been the warm one in a casual connection (I’ve also been there):

Clarity is a kindness.

Saying “I don’t want a relationship” once doesn’t cut it when your actions say something different every single day.

Kindness without clarity can leave someone guessing for years.

Whichever side you’re on, it helps to know your own code.

Which behaviors mean “we’re together” to you?

And where might you be wishtening?

That’s exactly what we could untangle in a free 15-minute Big Ask consultation.

We’ll decode your couple-coded behaviors, spot where signals are getting crossed (yours or theirs), and get clear on what you actually want to ask for.

👉 Book your Big Ask here: https://my.curiouser.life/15-minutes-big-ask

Because the right person won’t just be kind to you.

They’ll be clear with you, too.

Nookie Signature

--
Rev Heather, aka Nookie, LUQ
https://my.curiouser.life
+1-855-712-5433 (toll-free)

P.S. What’s the one behavior that flips your relationship switch? A good morning text? A toothbrush at their place? Being introduced to their friends or their dog, Sir Sniffsalot?

Hit reply and tell me. And if you’ve ever been on the other side, the one who was “just being nice,” I want to hear that story too.

Back to Blog